Where’s Xavier? The real reason Percy Hynes White isn't returning as Xavier in Wednesday Season 2

The new season of Wednesday is finally here, packed with mysteries, new characters, and darker storylines. But while most of the cast returned, one big face is missing: Percy Hynes White as Xavier Thorp. If you watched Season 1, you’ll remember he wasn’t just another student.

He was a psychic, a family friend, and even a possible love interest for Wednesday. So why is he gone in Season 2? Let’s break down both the story explanation and the real-world reasons behind his disappearance.

In Season 1, Xavier played a key role in Wednesday’s life. He was accused of being the Hyde killer, only to be cleared later when the real culprit was revealed.

Beyond that, he showed quiet loyalty, psychic abilities, and a deeper understanding of Wednesday’s visions. The finale even hinted at a growing friendship, maybe even more. That’s why fans expected to see much more of him in Season 2.

When Season 2 premiered, fans quickly noticed something was off. Xavier was nowhere to be seen at Nevermore Academy. Considering how Season 1 ended, his complete disappearance felt strange. It left many wondering what happened to him, both in the story and behind the scenes.

In Episode 1, the mystery is explained. Xavier’s father, Vincent Thorp, decides to pull his son out of Nevermore Academy.

Even though Xavier was proven innocent, being falsely accused of murder left scars. Vincent no longer trusted the school and didn’t want his son back in a place where his life could be in danger.

Xavier is now studying at Reichenbach Academy in Switzerland. This boarding school has a rich history in outcast education, and Gomez Addams even mentions studying there once. It’s prestigious but far away, basically taking Xavier out of Wednesday’s world.

Back in May 2024, Netflix confirmed Percy Hynes White would not be returning for Season 2. The announcement was quiet, but it revealed the show was moving away from the Season 1 love triangle.

Some fans disliked the romantic tension between Xavier, Wednesday, and Tyler. Dropping Xavier allowed the writers to shift focus toward new characters and darker mysteries instead of teenage romance.

---

Allegations and public controversy about Percy Hynes White’s absence in Wednesday Season 2

The situation became more complicated in January 2023, when online allegations of sexual assault surfaced against Percy Hynes White. He denied them, saying the claims were false and spread by someone he had never met. While Netflix never said the allegations were the reason for his removal, the timing raised eyebrows.

Jenna Ortega, who plays Wednesday, addressed his absence in an interview. She called it “a weird redirect” but noted that Season 2 introduces so many fresh characters that most viewers might not dwell too much on Xavier’s exit. The rest of the cast and crew have mostly stayed quiet about it.

Even though he’s physically gone, the writers didn’t completely erase Xavier. In Episode 1, she receives a note and a painting from him.

The painting shows a one-eyed crow from one of Xavier’s visions. Fans know his art often hints at deeper truths, so this new symbol might connect to the season’s mystery.

By sending Xavier overseas, the writers closed his chapter for now but left the door open for a return. With mentions of Vincent Thorp and the mysterious Reichenbach Academy, there are plenty of ways the show could bring him back in a later season.

Without Xavier, Wednesday loses the one person who truly understood her visions. But this shift allows her story to dive deeper into mysteries rather than romantic drama. The show feels darker, stranger, and more focused on suspense.

Not surprisingly, fans are divided. Some miss Xavier’s steady presence and hope for more romance. Others are glad the love triangle is gone, saying it distracted from the spooky mystery vibe the show is known for.

So, is Xavier gone for good? It’s unclear. The show carefully left breadcrumbs that could bring him back. If Wednesday’s adventures eventually cross into Europe or if Reichenbach Academy plays a bigger role, we might just see Percy Hynes White again.

TV shows often change direction between seasons. Characters disappear, new ones arrive, and stories take fresh turns. While losing Xavier feels like a big shift, it also frees Wednesday to explore new territory. Sometimes, change is exactly what keeps a show alive.

Xavier Thorp’s absence in Wednesday Season 2 has both in-universe and real-world explanations. In the story, his father sent him away after the events of Season 1. Behind the scenes, Netflix decided not to bring back Percy Hynes White, possibly influenced by controversy and a desire to drop the love triangle subplot.

Still, his presence lingers through his visions, leaving fans hopeful for a return. Whether or not he comes back, Xavier’s absence has reshaped the show's world in ways that may ultimately make the show stronger.

---

For more updates, keep reading Soap Central.