Dateline: Sound And Fury covered the case of Tiffany Pugh, a 30-year-old wife and mother of two and a Delta Airlines flight attendant, who was murdered in her East Point, Georgia, home on November 23, 2014. Her husband, Andre Pugh—DJ Awesome was eventually found guilty of conspiring to murder her.
The crime, featured at the heart of Dateline NBC's "Sound and Fury" episode, rocked the community and raised grisly questions of betrayal, spousal abuse, and cold-blooded homicide.
What police investigators learned is that Tiffany was a target of a murder-for-hire scheme orchestrated by her husband and his friend, Adrian Harley. This wasn't a pointless act of brutality—it was an execution of chilling murder that unraveled a wretchedly diabolical family situation.
The "Sound and Fury" segment of Dateline constructs this case from court records, interviews, and evidence that reveal the extent of betrayal and the savagery of the crime.
Warning: This article discusses and contains a description of murder. Viewers discretion is advised.
Here's the trailer of the episode for your reference:
Who was Tiffany Pugh in Dateline: Sound And Fury
Tiffany Pugh, as shown in Dateline, was a devoted mother, a good airline employee, and by all accounts, someone who kept her travails strictly under wraps. She worked at Delta Airlines and lived with her husband, Andre, and their kids in an Atlanta suburb just outside the city limits of Atlanta.
Her friends and family said she was reserved, gentle, and intensely committed to her children. She maintained a low profile on social media and largely shunned the limelight. In her home, though, Tiffany and Andre's union was said to be on shaky ground. Financial problems, emotional distance, and allegations of infidelity had created deep cracks in their relationship.
The night of the incident: A horrifying discovery
As depicted in Dateline: Sound And Fury, in the early morning hours of November 23, 2014, Andre Pugh made a 911 call reporting a potential break-in. When police came to the Pugh home, what they encountered was much worse than a break-in. Tiffany had been shot several times in the master bedroom. Even worse, her two-year-old son was found in the same room, attempting to rouse his lifeless mother.
There were no signs of forced entry, and police assumed that the killer had either been invited in or had a house key. Andre told police he had been doing a DJ show that night and returned home the next morning to find the scene of the crime. However, police found discrepancies in his story, especially when forensic evidence began surfacing.
The investigation: Digital evidence cracks the case
Dateline: Sound And Fury revealed that cell phone records, security footage, and text messages – all played a critical role in piecing together the timeline. Investigators zeroed in on Adrian Harley—Andre's best friend and co-DJ. GPS tracking placed Harley near the scene of the crime at the time of the murder, and security cameras caught a car matching his description in the area.
Further examination of the exchange of messages between Harley and Andre revealed frequent messages weeks before the murder. This led the police to believe that Harley had been hired by Andre to kill Tiffany. Evidence brought to court showed that Andre had paid Harley for the services of killing Tiffany.
Trial and convictions: Justice for Tiffany
As per Dateline: Sound And Fury, in 2018, Andre Pugh was found guilty of malice murder, felony murder, and conspiracy to murder following years of delay and investigation. He received a life sentence without parole. It was the case of the prosecution that Andre had been motivated by financial stress and personal resentment and had taken advantage of his close relationship with Harley to perpetrate the offense.
Adrian Harley was also tried and detained separately. He was found guilty and handed the same—life without parole in 2022. Harley maintained his innocence throughout the trial, but the jury felt that the evidence mounted against him.
The role of domestic tensions
The trial put renewed focus on hidden domestic conflicts. Their marriage had been strained for years, according to testimony. Allegations of infidelity and emotional abuse were raised. Andre reportedly kept up the glamorous public image of a successful radio disc jockey as their home finances were in disarray.
Witnesses testified that Tiffany was starting to consider divorce as a possibility. She was also reported to be trying to have a stable home for her children despite marital issues. The prosecutors felt Andre saw Tiffany's potential departure as a threat—emotionally, financially, and socially.
The community reacts: Shock in the music scene
The Atlanta music scene was stunned. Andre Pugh was a respected figure as DJ Awesome, spinning at hip clubs and parties. He was a familiar face in local entertainment circles. Most who knew him could not reconcile the cheerful public persona with the evil accusations.
The "Dateline: Sound And Fury" featured opinions from Atlanta rapper Jeezy as well as some of the community members who were dismayed and shocked by the situation. The gap between Andre's public image and the private lives in his marriage became a public focus of debate after the trial.
Impact on the children and legacy
Tiffany's children were left without parents. They were left in the care of extended family. The psychological weight on her children and kin was immense. Her family has since remained low-key, with few public statements aside from those made in the courtroom.
Though the convictions were an act of justice, the traumatic event of the incident still echoes in the lives of all the individuals concerned. The case also brought into focus the need for increased awareness about domestic violence and hidden abuse.
Tiffany Pugh's murder wasn't just another murder—it was a carefully planned crime committed by one of her closest acquaintances. Dateline's "Sound And Fury" illuminates the case at a national level and highlights how quickly domestic strife, without checks and balances, can degenerate into horror beyond imagination.
The investigation of Tiffany's homicide is a warning of the dangers of ignoring early red flags in relationships. It is also a case of the crucial role of online data in cracking modern-day crimes. In general, the case is a harsh reminder of the betrayal, justice, and scarring that remain.
Also read: Dateline: The Last Mile - Everything we know about the latest true crime episode